Tuesday, October 07, 2008
The TL;DR of Previews
Let's sum this up real quick for the Devils; the previews all tend to agree on the following:
- Martin Brodeur is the strength of the team
- But he's getting older. (Imagine! People! Getting! Older! Damn you, Persistence of Time!)
- The defense doesn't have any big names, but they do a decent enough job.
- Scoring/forwards needs to be better
- Signing Brian Rolston was an excellent decision.
- Doubting Lou is a bad choice. (Duh)
Where do they disagree? Easy - when it comes to figuring out how good the Devils are. Despite claims that they can't be counted out, some previews show them in the bottom end of the playoff seeding in the East. Maybe it's telling of how competitive the division, conference, and the league now are; but who knows. Others go in an opposite direction and think they can finish first in the whole conference, much less the division. From my point of view (and my count), the amount of optimistic and pessimistic is about even (with 2MA stuck in the middle!). OK, maybe there are other previews I missed - but from a sample of 15 from both print and the Internet of various areas (Devils fans, big hockey bloggers, etc.), this is what I found. Yes, there are more pessimistic predictions out there for the Devils and based on legitimate concerns. But, it isn't fair or true at all to say that mostly everyone in the hockey world doesn't respect the Devils or their chances. Only one preview comes right out and says they won't make the playoffs (and two are iffy), after all. We're going to see the postseason come to Newark again, the Devils should be that good. How well New Jersey will do - whether they will have home ice again or get in on the final days of April - is the sticking point.
I put all of my thoughts and the links (where possible) to each preview into the following table, so you can judge for yourself.
I put all of my thoughts and the links (where possible) to each preview into the following table, so you can judge for yourself.
Preview | Prediction / Optimistic or Pessimistic? |
---|---|
NHL.com | No Prediction / Optimistic |
Adam Heika | First in the East / Quite Optimistic |
2 Man Advantage | No Prediction / Not Optimistic,or Really Pessimistic |
NHL Yearbook | Fourth in Atlantic, Ninth in the East / Pessimistic |
Sporting News NHL Preview | Fourth in Atlantic, Playoffs??? / Pessimistic |
McKeen's 2008-2009 Yearbook | Fourth in Atlantic, Tied for Eighth in the East / Pessimistic (and a bit odd) |
Dan Di Sciullo | Playoffs / Optimistic |
Greg Wyshynski @ Puck Daddy | Second or Third in Atlantic, Playoffs / Optimistic to a point |
Greg Wyshynski @ Pensblog | This preview sucks / Pessimistic |
Interchangeable Parts | No team prediction / Interchangeably Pessimistic (or Ookie-mistic) |
Pam @ MYFO | Playoffs / Pessimistic |
The Hockey News Yearbook | Seventh in the East / Pessimistic |
James Mirtle | First in the East / Optimistic |
Pierre LeBrun @ ESPN | No clear prediction here, but earlier said that they won't make the playoffs. But it states another postseason run is possible. Changed his mind? / Cautiously Optimistic |
Kevin Schultz @ NHL FanHouse | FanHouse prediction in detail - but Playoffs / Optimistic |
Labels: 2008-09 Preseason, 2008-09 Season, Devils Analysis, Devils Issues, Hockey - General, Media
Comments:
<< Home
i'd stay away from anything that ESPN says cause they hate the devils' organization for not being 'media friendly enough...at least IMHO
Post a Comment
<< Home